Historical test result
Few trades a year, 30 % drawdown.
The pre-holiday strategy traded only around holidays and still fell 30 % at 2x. You would lose about $30,000 on a $100,000 challenge account, which is far beyond the loss limit that ends most challenges. Drawdown means the fall from a high point to a low point. That size means you trade twice the money in your account.
You may think a quiet plan keeps you safe because it trades so rarely. A few trades a year cannot cause a big drawdown.
I thought the same before I ran my own test. My test showed the opposite, and it changed how I check a plan before I pay a fee.
Why a quiet plan feels safe
You see only a small number of trades on the calendar, and you feel calm. You think the market can hurt you only when you are in the market, so less time inside looks like less danger. You also see long quiet weeks with no loss, and you start to trust the calm. That trust feels natural when you want to pass and you do not want to pay for a new try.
Your friend may tell you the same story. He says he leaves the market alone for most of the year and he picks only a rare moment. You hear that and you think risk must stay small because action stays small. You picture a small bill for a small mistake, and you picture your account staying near where it started.
That picture misses how size works. A rare trade can still use large size, and a large size can still push your account far down in a short time. You do not need many losses to face a deep hole. You need only a small set of trades that move hard against you while your size stays large.
What my test covered
I ran the same idea on 7 stock indices from 2017 to 2023. At 1x with no stop and no costs, it still fell about 10 %. A stop is an order that closes your trade when the loss gets too large.
I kept the rules plain and I left the test simple so you can see the point fast. I did not add filters or extra timing, and I did not pick only the calm years. You see the full stretch with good stretches and rough stretches mixed in as they came.
The point is not the holiday itself. The point is that a plan with rare action still lived through rough patches that pulled the account down hard. You may love rare trades, but you still must face what rare trades did when the market turned.
What that fall means for your challenge
Your challenge ends when your loss hits the limit your firm set. It does not matter if you traded each day or only on rare days. The firm looks at your account value, and it stops you when that value drops too far.
That is why a deep fall hurts even when it comes from rare trades. You pay the fee and you trade with care. Then a rough patch pulls you under the line. You are out, and you must decide if you want to pay again and try again.
I never trust a quiet plan until I have seen its largest fall against the loss limit.
You should look at the money, not at the calendar. Ask how many dollars that fall would take from your account, and ask if your limit could survive it. If the answer scares you, you have learned something before you paid.
How you check your own report in five minutes
You can do this check in five minutes on your own report. Open your own report, find the largest fall from a high point, and compare it with your loss limit.
Look for the curve that shows your account value through time, not only the list of closed trades. Find the highest point before a drop and the lowest point after it starts. That gap is the fall you must respect.
If that gap is near your limit, your plan leaves you no room for a bad patch. If that gap is far smaller than your limit, you still must read the rules of your firm with care. Your firm decides, and its dashboard is the final word.
Do not judge a plan by how calm it looks. Judge it by how deep its worst fall goes. Ask whether you could stay in the game after it.
What to do before you pay
You want to pass, so you want a plan that fits the limit. Take your report and write down the largest fall in dollars. Put that number next to the loss limit of your challenge. You will see at once if the plan asks for more room than your challenge gives.
If you have no report yet, ask for one or run a plain test on past prices. Use simple rules you can explain to a friend. Keep costs in mind, and keep your size honest. You do not need a perfect test to learn if a plan is too wild for your limit.
I keep this step short because you do not need more theory. You need a clear view of the worst fall and a clear view of your limit. When those views sit side by side, you can choose with calm.
Sources and limits
Original question (https://www.instagram.com/reel/DfCCRnNlPfM/)
These are historical test results, not a live account.
Try the free Prop Rule Guard here: https://stratcorealpha.com/rule-guard?ref=website.